Butler Manor Real Estate Staten Island

Butler Manor is an upscale neighborhood on Staten Island's South Shore. Technically part of the affluent Tottenville neighborhood, Butler Manor real estate is comprised of luxury custom-built homes in a highly sought-after gated community.

Find out more about Butler Manor real estate, or see all Butler Manor homes for sale below.

Butler Manor Homes for Sale

All Listings $400,000 - $500,000 $500,000 - $600,000
$600,000 - $700,000 Over $1,000,000
11 Properties Found. Showing Page 1 of 1
View As: Thumbnails List Map
Sort by:

One Of A Kind Waterfro...

$3,700,000
Staten Island, NY
4 br, 7 ba, 7,848 ft² Residential
Price:
$3,700,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
4
Baths:
7
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1085664

One Of A Kind Waterfront Mansion Untouched By Sandy Dramatic Entry, Soaring Ceilings,7248 Exquisi...

Photo of Listing #1085664

Beautiful 4 Br Center ...

$2,850,000
Staten Island, NY
4 br, 4 ba, 5,000 ft² Residential
Price:
$2,850,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
4
Baths:
4
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1076738

Beautiful 4 Br Center Hall Colonial W/2 Story Fam Room, 3 Car Garage, Full Basement.

Photo of Listing #1076738

Superb Colonial To Be ...

$2,650,000
Staten Island, NY
4 br, 5 ba, 6,865 ft² Residential
Price:
$2,650,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
4
Baths:
5
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1083212

Superb Colonial To Be Built In Tottenville's Premier All Custom Community, Spectacular Environmen...

Photo of Listing #1083212

One Of A Kind, Custom ...

$2,100,000
Staten Island, NY
6 br, 6 ba, 6,499 ft² Residential
Price:
$2,100,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
6
Baths:
6
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1084718

One Of A Kind, Custom Built 2 Family Chc W/ Over Approx. 6500 Sq Ft Of Living Space. This Brick/s...

Photo of Listing #1084718

In This Beautiful Wate...

$1,760,000
Staten Island, NY
5 br, 7 ba, 5,984 ft² Residential
Price:
$1,760,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
5
Baths:
7
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1089941

In This Beautiful Waterfront Community Sits This "castle" Of A Home With Too Many Amenities To Li...

Photo of Listing #1089941

Magnificent All Brick ...

$1,325,000
Staten Island, NY
8 br, 7 ba, 7,000 ft² Residential
Price:
$1,325,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
8
Baths:
7
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1056504

Magnificent All Brick Custom Chc, Over 5,500 Sq Ft Of Living Space, 3 Story Entry Foyer, Sky Parl...

Photo of Listing #1056504

Elegant Center Hall Co...

$1,085,000
Staten Island, NY
3 br, 3 ba, 3,900 ft² Residential
Price:
$1,085,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
3
Baths:
3
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1087346

Elegant Center Hall Colonial In Desirable Tottenville. Stately Oak & Ceramic Floors, Beautiful E...

Photo of Listing #1087346

1420r: Mint, Spacious ...

$1,049,000
Staten Island, NY
7 br, 5 ba, 3,700 ft² Residential
Price:
$1,049,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
7
Baths:
5
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1090648

1420r: Mint, Spacious Describes Huge 2 Family Princess Estate Chc W/full Finished Bsmt Designed F...

Photo of Listing #1090648

Decorators Delight, Th...

$695,000
Staten Island, NY
4 br, 4 ba, 3,411 ft² Residential
Price:
$695,000
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
4
Baths:
4
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1090417

Decorators Delight, This 4 Bedroom Chc Home On Quiet Cul-de-sac Offers Custom Moldings, Radiant H...

Photo of Listing #1090417

Located With Public Tr...

$538,888
Staten Island, NY
3 br, 3 ba, 1,950 ft² Residential
Price:
$538,888
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
3
Baths:
3
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1089942

Located With Public Transportation Nearby, This Exceptionally Nice Home Has A Spacious Living And...

Photo of Listing #1089942

House Fronts Camden No...

$454,900
Staten Island, NY
3 br, 3 ba, 2,100 ft² Residential
Price:
$454,900
City:
Staten Island
Beds:
3
Baths:
3
Type:
Residential
MLS® #:
1083301

House Fronts Camden Not Hylan. Beautiful Extra Wide 1 Family Colonial Upgrades Galore, New Roof ...

Photo of Listing #1083301

Butler Manor Homes

Butler Manor homes vary from spectacular oceanfront properties filled with incredible features, to elegant modern townhouses.

Elmer Butler, a maritime and shipping magnate, built the original Butler Manor in 1908. The house was demolished, and its grounds developed to create the modern community of Butler Manor.

Nearby, you'll find the historic Conference House, which was built in 1678 by Christopher Billop. It was named The Conference House, following a 1776 meeting that was held there to negotiate an end to the Revolutionary War. It is now a part of a 267-acre state park, and those who call Butler Manor home enjoy access to the popular visitor center, waterfront pavilion, hiking trails and a children's playground.

Childrens' educational needs are fulfilled by Tottenville High School and IS34. There are a few elementary schools nearby, including PS6, PS1 and Our Lady Help of Christians, which opened in 1904.

Are you thinking of buying or selling Butler Manor real estate? For professional advice and assistance, please contact RealEstateSINY today.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Listing data is deemed reliable but it not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Listing information is provided by the Staten Island Board of REALTORS®.

Sell With Us!

Agent Spotlight

Cynthia Dgheim

Cynthia Dgheim
Associate Broker
(718) 966-9669 Realtorcyn@gmail.com

Request Value Report
map search

Follow Us

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google Profile Youtube Pinterest
Sell Your Home

Home Seller's Guide

A well-priced home will generate competing offers and drive up the final sale value. Our free market analysis takes into account the most actively searched prices and home values in the area and provides you with a detailed evaluation that puts it all in perspective.

Our tried and true marketing plan will take the guesswork out of selling your home.

Use the search tools on this site to get an idea of the competition.

Contact us anytime you need to know what's really going on in this market. When you're ready to take the next step toward selling your home, we're here to help. We'll make sure your listing gets the best exposure and reaches the right buyer—whether they're out of state, in another country, or right around the corner.

Sell Your Home

Want to know what your home is currently worth?

Fill out the form below for your free evaluation report:

* Indicates a Required Field.

Your Contact Information
Property Information

Please list the additional amenities of your house.

*Your information will not be shared.