46 Bay 37th, Brooklyn, New York

$2,199,000

Previous Next

5

Baths

3,960

Square feet

About 46 Bay 37th

Rare opportunity to own an oversized, custom-built 4-family brick home with a private driveway for up to 3 cars in the heart of Bensonhurst! Proudly built and occupied by the original owner since 1963, South-facing orientation (sitting North, facing South) provides abundant natural light, this meticulously maintained property is in move-in condition, and the house will be delivered vacant — a perfect chance for both end-users and investors. The house offers a total of 3,960 sqft of living space, plus an additional 1,408 sqft basement. All units have separate entrances. First Floor 22’ x 64’, totaling 1,408 sqft and divided into two apartments (1F & 1R), approximately 700 sqft each. Second Floor 22’ x 58’ (excluding balconies) and features a spacious 3-bedroom layout with a living room and front & rear balconies. The third floor, also 22’ x 58’, offers a bright and airy 4-bedroom configuration. Basement 22'x64 providing additional usable space. Utilities include 4 gas meters and 5 electric meters. Just minutes from the subway, and within a top-rated school zone, close to supermarkets, banks, restaurants, and all daily conveniences. Perfect for self-use with rental income or as a full investment property—stable high rental return potential Whether for self-use with rental income or a full investment property, this is a rare gem you don’t want to miss! .

Features of 46 Bay 37th

MLS® # 496853
Price $2,199,000
Bathrooms 5.00
Full Baths 4
Square Footage 3,960
Year Built 1963
Type Multi-Family
Sub-Type Multi-Family
Status Active

Community Information

Address 46 Bay 37th
Area Bath Beach
City Brooklyn
County Kings (Brooklyn)
State New York
Zip Code 11214

Amenities

Amenities NONE
Features None
Is Waterfront No
Has Pool No

Interior

Interior Hardwood, Tile
Heating Hot Water
Fireplace No
# of Stories 3
Has Basement Yes
Basement Finished, Full, Separate Entrance

Exterior

Exterior Brick
Roof Pitched
Construction Brick
Foundation Block

Additional Information

Date Listed October 23rd, 2025
Days on Market 1
Zoning R5
Tax $25,375

Listing Map

Request a Showing

Provide a valid email address.
When would you like to view this property?